The Hoodlum Saint

William Powell

Terence Ellerton 'Terry' O'Neill

Esther Williams

Kay Lorrison

Angela Lansbury

Dusty Millard

James Gleason

Snarp

Lewis Stone

Father Nolan

Rags Ragland

Fishface

Frank McHugh

Three Finger

Slim Summerville

Eel

Roman Bohnen

Father O'Doul

Charles Arnt

Cy Nolan - O'Neill's Secretary

Louis Jean Heydt

Mike Flaherty

Charles Trowbridge

Uncle Joe Lorrison

Henry O'Neill

Lewis J. Malbery

William Phillips

Dave Fernby

Matt Moore

Father Duffy

Trevor Bardette

Rabbi Meyerberg

Addison Richards

Reverend Miller

Tom Dugan

Buggsy

Emma Dunn

Maggie

Mary Gordon

Trina

Charles D. Brown

Ed Collner - Chronicle Reporter

Stanley Andrews

Chronicle Publisher (uncredited)

Stanley Blystone

Cop Arresting Fishface (uncredited)

Hobart Cavanaugh

Antique Clock Dealer (uncredited)