Alchemy

Tom Cavanagh

Mal Downey

Sarah Chalke

Samantha Rose

James Barbour

Dr. Troy Rollins

Michael Ian Black

Jerry (voice)

Nadia Dajani

Jane

Illeana Douglas

KJ

Celeste Holm

Iris

Logan Marshall-Green

Martin

Wil Horneff

Dave

Shannon McGinnis

Barbara

Anna Belknap

Marissa

Tovah Feldshuh

Senior Editor

Daphne Rubin-Vega

Belladonna Editor

Susan Misner

Associate Editor

Erik Palladino

Groom

Catherine Kellner

Bride

Ajay Naidu

Best Man

Marisa Ryan

Bridesmaid

Stephen Bogardus

Father of Bride

Daniel Cantor

Philly Phil

Ann McDonough

Mother of Bride

Zack Abramowitz

Restaurant Patron (uncredited)

Bryan Ayres

Angry Student

Gavin Bailey

Martin's Best Man