Paint It Black

Alia Shawkat

Josie

Janet McTeer

Meredith

Rhys Wakefield

Michael

Nancy Kwan

Margaret

Emily Rios

Pen

Alfred Molina

Cal

Mish Way

Lola Lola

Austin Barber

Man in Crowd

Terry Kinney

Detective Brooks (voice)

Beau Sia

Phil

Amanda Shokrian

Cellist at the Funeral

Jesse Nolan

Ben Sinister

Ashley Blaine Featherson-Jenkins

Shirley Mae

Annabelle Attanasio

Amanda One

Simon Helberg

Jeremy

Tom Nolan

Restaurant Patron

Rudy Dobrev

Conrad

Chris Palko

Nick Nitro

Corrina Bain

Punk in the Bar

Bucky Sinister

Bartender

John Marshall Jones

Officer Jones

Lucas Hubert

Young Michael

Katelyn Millette

Young Meredith

Russ Tamblyn

Meredith's Friend